Finrot.....I started that other thread because there wasn't much information about the reels, and I had bought two of them from Veals. Someone mentioned that these reels were simple Chinese junk, with an Akios rebadge. Well.....we bought the cheap reel that was said to be the exact same thing, and it wasn't even close. So now we got a junk Chinese reel in the drawer. No one wants to fish with it. LOL
I have never tried the Shimano you mentioned, but it seems to have a loyal following. If choosing between the two, and you need a new reel soon, it would be an easy choice to make. Get the Shimano, as no one really knows about the R10's durability yet.
I have three Daiwa Emblem Pro A reels and a Penn Surf Blaster, and they now sit in my drawer of unwanted reels. So I would say the Akios are easily better than those.
I fish clean sandy beaches, where an extreme distance cast can make the difference between sitting and watching my rods, or catching fish. My normal targeted species don't get above ten pounds, so a powerful reel was not what I needed. I needed distance. The R10 definitely delivers distance. The line peels off so freely and easily that it is hard to see or feel it leaving the spool. Very nice.
Any long stroke reel is susceptible to being damaged from a large powerful fish. The reels known for strength are all short stroke designs. However, I did land a five foot shark with my R10 this past Sunday morning. Didn't baby the reel, just did my normal thing and put him on the sand. Along the way I never felt I was at a disadvantage. The drag worked like a drag is supposed to work. The reel seems just fine to me now. No noticble wobbles or grinding sounds.
I haven't done another measured cast, but really want to hit my goal of 200 yards with baited rig. Have fished the reels about ten times now, so not a lot to say about durability. The line has not given me any issues. I even attached a lure and threw it for a while. I felt I was getting excellent distance, and if I was going to have line issues, they would have been created then.
I also own the Akios 100 that came out prior to the R10, and have fished with it many times. It also has managed some larger fish without issues. Still seems like new to me. It also casts nicely, but Not as nicely as the latest design.
I use thirteen foot rods with low rider guides, Den's mechanical releases, 30 lb Daiwa JBraid main line and 100 lb Maxquattro shock leaders. Very happy to have these reels.